Things That Simply Should Not Be Done

Editors Note: This article appeared in Salvo 34, Summer 2015 edition and is used by permission.

Head Transplants: Semantic Inversion and Moral Aversion

Earlier this year, Dr. Sergio Canavero announced that he would attempt a head transplant within two years. His confident claims aside, the first problem with his statement is a semantic inversion. The “organ” that a donor would provide is not their head, but their body. The goal is to extend the life of a person with degenerative muscular or nerve disease or metastasized cancer by attaching their healthy head to a healthy donor body. Thus, we are actually talking about body transplantation.

The first head/body transplants were attempted on dogs in 1954, and on a monkey in 1970. None lived more than nine days.[1] A human head transplant attempt has never been reported.

The proposed technique would involve cooling the head and the donor body to extend the amount of time they could survive without oxygen, using a “magic ingredient” to fuse the spinal cords, and inducing a post-transplant coma to prevent movement.

Medical community reaction ranged from skepticism (“It won’t work”) to disdain (“It’s a PR stunt”) to dismissal (“The guy is a bona fide lone ranger”) to concern (“Even attempting the experiment is unethical and bad science”). Despite widespread objections, Canavero is soliciting funds and a medical team.

Whether or not Canavero succeeds, his proposal raises serious ethical concerns. One is the violation of research standards. A significant volume of bench and animal research—completely absent here—is required before attempting human research. Second, as Dr. Gregory Rutecki points out, nonvital transplants such as a face transplant require “intensive counseling over and over about the patient’s stability and psychological state.”[2] This, too, is missing from Canavero’s proposal. If a face transplant can change one’s sense of identity, how much more would a body transplant?

Philosophers also care about personal identity. What makes you the same person over time, whether an embryo, infant, teen, or adult? Is it your whole body, or simply your brain? Philosopher Derek Parfit suggests that the relevant question is “the continuity of our mental or psychological metaphysical narrative.”[3]  Similarly, neurologist and bioethicist Dr. Patricia Scripko says that what makes us specifically human “is held within the higher cortex.”[4] But, memories are stored not just in brain cells. Some heart transplant patients develop the donor’s food, sex, and artistic preferences, and even aspects of their personality.[5] An artificial divide between brain (relevant) and body (irrelevant) leaves no room for embodied or immaterial aspects of identity, including the human soul.

A further ethical concern is a practical one. At a cost of $11 million, the proposed transplant will require 150 doctors and nurses. A donor’s body could save up to eight lives and benefit many more through organ and tissue transplants.[6] And $11 million could go a long way toward curing the underlying diseases. Meanwhile, Canavero’s “magic ingredient” could help spinal cord injury patients now.

But, ethical warnings and practical objections may not deter a brash surgeon and a desperate candidate. Valery Spiridonov, a 30-year-old computer scientist from Russia has volunteered.[7] I wonder, would he object to having a woman’s body?

 

Reference


[1] Helen Thompson, “First human head transplant could happen in two years,” New Scientist (Feb. 25, 2015), http://tinyurl.com/q6e6klh; Robert J. White, Maurice S. Albin, George E. Locke, Eugene Davidson, “Brain Transplantation: Prolonged Survival of Brain after Carotid-Jugular Interposition,” Science 150, no. 3697 (1965): 779-781.

[2] Personal communication, Mar. 31, 2015.

[3] J.S. Blumenthal-Barby, “Head Transplants, Personal Identity, and Derek Parfit,” Bioethics.net (March 30, 2015), http://tinyurl.com/nccdre9.

[4] Thompson.

[5] Lizete Borelli, “Can an Organ Transplant Change a Recipient’s Personality?” Medical Daily (July 9, 2013), http://tinyurl.com/l69yfyp.

[7] “Revolutionary: Russian man to undergo first head-to-body transplant.” RT News April 10, 2015, http://tinyurl.com/n4fqz9f

 

Creative Commons License